Book Hotels in Middle Island, NY
Cabins, apartments, houseboats! We offer comfortable & private vacation rentals
Save an extra 10% or more on select hotels with Member Discounts
Access exclusive hotel deals, only with the Travelocity app
Top Middle Island hotels
Holiday Inn Long Island-Islip Arpt East by IHG
Hotel was very very clean!!!
Reviewed on Jan 7, 2026
Home2 Suites by Hilton Long Island Brookhaven
This was a very clean, beautiful hotel. The staff was very helpful and accommodating. We were regretting the fact that we were only staying one night because it was so nice. The location is great - there were several little restaurants within walking distance.
Reviewed on Jan 8, 2026
Holiday Inn Express Stony Brook by IHG
Check in was easy and front desk offered options and confirmed preferences. Room was super clean, bed was comfortable. Shower was a bit low pressure but maybe because we requested higher floor. Breakfast was okay, they ran out of yogurt but that was really it, everything else was 👌
Reviewed on Dec 28, 2025
Hampton Inn Long Island-Brookhaven
Friendly staff. Clean room, decent breakfast and good coffee. We especially appreciated the cold lemon water, hot water and coffee that were available in the lobby at all hours.
Reviewed on Jan 4, 2026
Hampton Inn Long Island/Islandia
Quiet, comfortable and easy access to highways.
Reviewed on Jan 9, 2026
Hyatt Regency Long Island
Hotel is clean, staff is friendly, restaurant is very good
Reviewed on Jan 1, 2026
Holiday Inn Express Hauppauge-Long Island
everything was amazing service, room food
Reviewed on Jan 7, 2026
La Quinta Inn & Suites by Wyndham Islip - MacArthur Airport
the room was warm and cozy, but still needed an update
Reviewed on Jan 8, 2026
Radisson Hotel Hauppauge-Long Island
Returning guest always a good stay no complaints.
Reviewed on Jan 7, 2026
Top reasons for your vacation to Middle Island
- Scenic Vineyard Views: Visit the Middleburgh Winery to enjoy the stunning views of the vineyards and sample local wines.
- Fascinating Underground Caves: Explore the Howe Caverns and take guided tours to witness unique geological formations in the underground cave system.
- Rich Historical Sites: History buffs can visit the Middleburgh Historical Society and the Middleburgh Heritage Area to learn about the region's rich past.
- Breathtaking Hiking Trails: Discover the excellent hiking trails and breathtaking views of Hunter Mountain, located near Middle Island.
- Serenity and Friendly Locals: Middle Island offers a peaceful getaway with serene landscapes and friendly locals, perfect for relaxation and connecting with the community.
Find your favorite hotels in Middle Island
When it comes to finding hotel accommodations in or near Middle Island, you're in luck. There are a variety of options available to suit your needs. Whether you're looking for friendly hotels, featured motels, or suites, you'll find a range of choices. Additionally, many hotels in the area offer breakfast options, allowing you to start your day off right. So whether you're looking for a budget-friendly option or a luxurious stay, Middle Island has something for everyone.
| Hotel name | Type | Stars | Description |
| Hilton Garden Inn Shelton | Hotel | 3.0 | This 3.0-star rated hotel is located just 28.7 miles away from Middle Island. It is a great option for your outdoor vacation as it offers close proximity to kayaking, indoor pool, hot tub, golf, hiking, friendly people, connecting rooms, fitness center, concierge, and spa facilities. |
| Hampton Inn Long Island-Brookhaven | Hotel | 2.5 | With a 2.5-star rating, this hotel is only 5.5 miles away from Middle Island. It provides convenient access to free airport transportation, an indoor pool, airport nearby, islands, friendly people, golf, connecting rooms, a relaxing atmosphere, and a fitness center. |
| Hyatt Regency Long Island | Hotel | 3.5 | This 3.5-star rated hotel is situated 12.7 miles away from Middle Island. It offers close proximity to wedding venues, basketball courts, whale watching opportunities, skydiving spots, golf courses, friendly people, kayaking, an airport nearby, tennis courts, and an indoor pool. |
Explore the best activities and sights in Middle Island
For outdoor enthusiasts, Middle Island, New York offers a variety of activities and attractions. Visit the Middleburgh Winery to sample local wines and enjoy the scenic vineyard views. Explore the Howe Caverns, a fascinating underground cave system, where you can take guided tours and experience unique geological formations. History buffs can visit nearby historic sites like the Middleburgh Historical Society and the Middleburgh Heritage Area, which offer insights into the region's rich past. With its picturesque landscapes and proximity to other attractions, Middle Island is the perfect destination for a memorable outdoor vacation.
- Times Square: Times Square is a vibrant and bustling square located in the heart of New York City. It is known for its dazzling neon lights, towering skyscrapers, and lively atmosphere. The square is home to numerous theaters, offering a wide range of Broadway shows and performances. Visitors can also explore the many art galleries and museums in the area, showcasing a diverse range of artistic styles. With its iconic architecture and vibrant energy, Times Square is a must-visit for those seeking an urban and artistic experience.
- Central Park: Central Park is an expansive and picturesque park nestled in the middle of Manhattan. It offers a peaceful oasis amidst the bustling city streets. The park is home to several world-class museums, including the Metropolitan Museum of Art and the American Museum of Natural History. Visitors can also enjoy scenic walking paths, beautiful gardens, and serene lakes. Central Park is perfect for families looking to enjoy outdoor activities such as picnics, bike rides, and boat rides. With its stunning scenery and cultural attractions, Central Park provides a unique blend of nature and city experiences.
- Statue of Liberty: The Statue of Liberty is an iconic symbol of freedom and democracy. Located on Liberty Island in New York Harbor, the statue offers breathtaking views of the city skyline and the surrounding skyscrapers. Visitors can take a ferry ride to the island and explore the museum inside the pedestal, learning about the history and significance of the statue. The experience of standing at the base of the statue and gazing up at her majestic figure is truly awe-inspiring. The Statue of Liberty is a must-visit for those interested in history, culture, and the beauty of New York City.
Where to stay in Middle Island
Get ready for an unforgettable outdoor vacation in Middle Island, New York! This charming town, located near the Catskill Mountains, offers a variety of activities for nature lovers. Explore the stunning Hunter Mountain, known for its excellent hiking trails and breathtaking views. Immerse yourself in the beauty of the Catskill Mountains as you embark on scenic drives and picnics surrounded by nature. Middle Island itself is a peaceful getaway with its serene landscapes and friendly locals. Whether you're seeking adventure or relaxation, Middle Island promises an idyllic outdoor vacation for you and your family.
- Gordon Heights: Gordon Heights is a charming city known for its serene atmosphere and scenic beauty. Located in the heart of Long Island, this region offers a unique outdoor experience for families. With its lush greenery, sprawling parks, and picturesque trails, Gordon Heights is an ideal destination for hiking, biking, and picnicking. Families can also explore the local wildlife and enjoy birdwatching in the nearby nature reserves. Additionally, Gordon Heights is home to several family-friendly attractions, including playgrounds, sports fields, and recreational facilities. Whether you're looking for a leisurely stroll or an adventurous outdoor activity, Gordon Heights has something to offer for everyone.
The travel seasons of Middle Island
Trips to Middle Island show no change in popularity throughout the year. The peak season to visit is from June to August, with July being the highest month. Off-peak season starts from October to December, and October sees the least travelers.
Middle Island has something in store for you whenever you visit. January is the coldest month of the year, while July is hottest, with average temperatures up to 75.0 degrees Fahrenheit. The wettest month in Middle Island is October, so pack accordingly.
 Calendar Month |  Temperature |  Precipitation |  Cloudiness |
| January | 34.0°F (1.1°C) | Light Rain | Mostly Sunny |
| February | 34.7°F (1.5°C) | Light Rain | Mostly Sunny |
| March | 39.9°F (4.4°C) | Light Rain | Mostly Sunny |
| April | 48.9°F (9.4°C) | Light Rain | Mostly Sunny |
| May | 58.3°F (14.6°C) | Light Rain | Mostly Sunny |
| June | 67.5°F (19.7°C) | Light Rain | Mostly Sunny |
| July | 75.0°F (23.9°C) | Light Rain | Mostly Sunny |
| August | 74.7°F (23.7°C) | Light Rain | Mostly Sunny |
| September | 68.7°F (20.4°C) | Light Rain | Mostly Sunny |
| October | 59.5°F (15.3°C) | Light Rain | Mostly Sunny |
| November | 48.7°F (9.3°C) | Light Rain | Mostly Sunny |
| December | 40.6°F (4.8°C) | Light Rain | Mostly Sunny |
Food and dining in Middle Island
While visiting Middle Island, New York, you won't be disappointed by the variety of local cuisines available. Bagels 101 is a highly rated and popular restaurant known for their delicious salads. If you're in the mood for Mediterranean Italian cuisine, Lombardi's Italian Restaurant is a moderately rated but highly popular choice. For Asian Chinese dishes, Good Wok Restaurant is another moderately rated and highly popular option. Whether you're craving a fresh salad, Italian pasta, or flavorful Chinese dishes, Middle Island has something to satisfy every food lover's taste buds.
How do I find a great hotel with Travelocity?
Ensure that your entire crew enjoys a memorable vacation by finding the ideal accommodations. Utilize our family-friendly badge to easily identify hotels that offer extra amenities for children. Moreover, our customized filters will assist you in narrowing down your search to hotels that are conveniently located near popular attractions, provide enhanced cleaning services, and fall within your budget range.
Why should I book with Travelocity?
Conference calls, to-do lists and, of course, football practice. Busy lives and packed schedules call for trips that are hassle-free. Our aim is to provide worry-free travel every time you and your family book with us so that you can spend less time worrying and more time creating lasting memories. To achieve this, we will assist you in finding and planning your ideal trip, along with offering transparent pricing and reliable reviews, and 24/7 guaranteed customer support before, during, and after your vacation.
How can I save money on my trip to Middle Island?
If you're planning a trip to Middle Island, New York, consider visiting during the less popular season from October to December. This can help you save money on accommodations and attractions. To further cut costs, consider bundling your flights, hotel, and car bookings to take advantage of discounted prices. By combining these expenses, you can simplify your trip planning and potentially save even more. Middle Island offers a range of activities for families, from exploring nature trails to visiting nearby beaches.
Frequently asked questions
Recent Middle Island hotel reviews by fellow wanderers
Hampton Inn Long Island/Islandia
Explore More Ways to Travel with Travelocity
- Manorville Hotels
- Gordon Heights Hotels
- Terryville Hotels
- B&B in Yaphank
- Cabins in Yaphank
- Beach Resorts & in Yaphank
- Pet Friendly Hotels in Yaphank
- Yaphank Hotels
- Motels in Yaphank
- Port Jefferson Hotels
- Hotels near Suffolk County Community College
- Hotels near Long Island Community Hospital Amphitheater
- Hotels near Mastic Shirley Station
- Hotels near Calverton National Cemetery
- Mount Sinai Hotels
- South Setauket Hotels
- Miller Place Hotels
- Holtsville Hotels
- Shirley Hotels
- New York Hotels
- 3 Star Hotels in Sound Beach
- B&B in Sound Beach
- Cabins in Sound Beach
- Cottages in Sound Beach
- Beach Resorts & in Sound Beach
- Cheap Hotels in Sound Beach
- Sound Beach Hotels
- Motels in Sound Beach
- Vacation Homes in Sound Beach
- Farmstay in Rocky Point
- B&B in Rocky Point
- Cabins in Rocky Point
- Cottages in Rocky Point
- Rocky Point Hotels
- Motels in Rocky Point
- Vacation Homes in Rocky Point
- Shoreham Hotels
- Hotels near Lasorda Legacy Park
- Extended Stay Hotels in Ridge
- Hotels with Pools in Ridge
- Resorts in Ridge
- Wading River Hotels
- Hotels near Boomers! Medford
- Hotels near Port Jefferson Station
- Hotels near Country Fair Entertainment Park
- Motels in East Shoreham
- Apartments in Medford
- B&B in Medford
- Condos in Medford
- Extended Stay Hotels in Medford
- Cheap Hotels in Medford
- Hotels with Pools in Medford
- Hotels with Hot Tubs in Medford
- Hotels with smoking rooms in Medford
- Spa Resorts & in Medford
- Medford Hotels
- Motels in Medford
- Vacation Homes in Medford
- Resorts in Medford
- Hotels near Theatre Three
- Port Jefferson Station Hotels
- Apartments in Coram
- B&B in Coram
- Cabins in Coram
- Condos in Coram
- Extended Stay Hotels in Coram
- Guest Houses in Coram
- Coram Hotels
- Inns in Coram
- Vacation Homes in Coram
- B&B in Selden
- Extended Stay Hotels in Selden
- Selden Hotels
- Motels in Selden
- Hotels near Brookhaven National Laboratory
- Apartments in Farmingville
- Condos in Farmingville
- Hotels with an Indoor Pool in Farmingville
- Farmingville Hotels
- Motels in Farmingville
